Gender Differences in Injury Risk: ACLs, Q-Angles, and Hormonal Factors

Why are women more likely to tear an ACL than men? Why do joint angles and hormones matter in injury prevention? These questions aren't just theoretical. They underpin some of the most consistent injury patterns seen in sport and performance. Understanding the interplay between biomechanics, hormonal fluctuations, and neuromuscular differences across genders is essential for designing safer, smarter training protocols.

Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) Injury: The Gender Gap

The ACL is one of the most frequently injured ligaments in athletes, particularly in cutting, jumping, or pivot-heavy sports. Numerous studies have shown that female athletes are 2 to 8 times more likely to sustain ACL injuries compared to their male counterparts in similar sports.

This discrepancy arises from a complex interaction between:

  • Biomechanical factors (e.g., joint angles, landing mechanics)
  • Hormonal variations (e.g., estrogen, relaxin)
  • Neuromuscular control (e.g., activation timing of stabilising muscles)

These factors do not work in isolation. They stack and compound, especially under fatigue or during certain phases of the menstrual cycle, increasing injury risk significantly.

Q-Angle: A Structural Risk Factor

The Q-angle (Quadriceps angle) refers to the angle formed by the quadriceps muscle’s line of pull and the patellar tendon. It is generally larger in females due to wider pelvises. A high Q-angle can result in:

  • Greater lateral pull on the patella
  • Increased stress on the medial knee structures
  • Altered biomechanics during running, jumping, or squatting

While not inherently “dangerous,” a higher Q-angle means the knees are more likely to collapse medially (valgus collapse) under dynamic movement — a position strongly correlated with ACL injuries.

Coaching Implications:

  • Focus on developing strong hip abductors and external rotators
  • Use neuromuscular reeducation drills that promote knee tracking control
  • Strengthen the posterior chain to counteract excessive quad dominance

Hormonal Influence: Estrogen and Relaxin

One of the most fascinating and under-discussed factors in injury prevention is the role of female sex hormones in joint stability.

Estrogen

Estrogen plays a role in collagen metabolism. During certain phases of the menstrual cycle — particularly around ovulation — estrogen levels spike and may reduce the stiffness of ligaments. This laxity, although adaptive in childbirth, can decrease joint stability in the knee.

Relaxin

Relaxin is another hormone that increases ligamentous laxity and soft tissue flexibility. It is more prominent during pregnancy but may also appear cyclically. Its presence can weaken the structural integrity of ligaments, especially the ACL.

Research suggests that these hormonal fluctuations may be partly why ACL injuries cluster during certain phases of the menstrual cycle.

Training Considerations:

  • Incorporate cycle tracking into athlete management for menstruating clients
  • Avoid very high-risk movements (e.g., depth jumps, aggressive cuts) during peak estrogen phases if neuromuscular control is lacking
  • Monitor fatigue and joint stability, especially mid-cycle

Neuromuscular Control and Proprioception Differences

Neuromuscular control refers to the body's ability to subconsciously activate stabilizing muscles during movement. Studies have shown that female athletes tend to:

  • Land with stiffer knees and less hip flexion
  • Activate quadriceps earlier and hamstrings later (increasing ACL load)
  • Display delayed glute activation and poor hip stabilization during single-leg tasks

These neuromuscular tendencies increase the risk of injury under sudden changes of direction, high-speed decelerations, or plyometric impact. In male athletes, a more balanced activation between hamstrings and quads, and greater hip drive, often buffers the ACL during similar movements.

Interventions and Correctives

With these differences in mind, training protocols must be adjusted with nuance. Injury prevention for women in particular should prioritize:

  • Glute and hamstring strength to counter anterior tibial translation
  • Plyometric drills with strict form control (e.g., landing softly, knees tracking)
  • Balance and proprioception exercises like single-leg RDLs or unstable surface work
  • Cycle-specific programming to reduce stress on ligaments during hormonal laxity phases

Education is equally vital. Female athletes should be made aware of their body’s unique physiology and how it may impact injury risk — not to limit them, but to empower them with tools to train intelligently and build resilient structures.

Adapt, Don’t Avoid

Biological sex differences in ACL injury risk are well-documented, but they are not a limitation — they are a coaching opportunity. Through a deeper understanding of biomechanics, hormonal influences, and neuromuscular patterns, we can design programs that reduce injury incidence while enhancing performance.

Whether coaching elite female athletes or gen pop clients, this knowledge allows us to be both precise and preventative in our approach — laying the foundation for strength, resilience, and sustainable movement for life.

Back to blog